Federalism in Antitrust
47 Pages Posted: 4 Oct 2005
Date Written: September 2002
Abstract
Several scholars have suggested that states should play a much more limited role in antitrust enforcement, especially in matters that are national or global in scope. In this paper, we analyze the states' part in the Microsoft case - a case that illustrates the costs of state intervention in antitrust matters that extend beyond state borders. Here, the states' involvement lengthened the lawsuit, complicated the settlement process, and increased both legal uncertainty and litigation costs. These results followed from the states' focus on parochial interests rather than broader concerns for efficiency and equity. We conclude that a state's antitrust enforcement authority should be restricted in matters that extend beyond its borders.
After analyzing the motivations for state behavior in federal antitrust, we consider whether restrictions should apply to federal antitrust authorities in cases with international implications. Though a global competition authority could, in principle, be designed to maximize economic well-being, practical and political obstacles appear to rule this option out, at least in the short term.
Keywords: antitrust, federalism, states, enforcement
JEL Classification: L40
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Staples-Office Depot and Up-Sp: An Antitrust Tale of Two Proposed Mergers
-
Market Definition in Monopolization Cases: A Paradigm is Missing
-
By Philip B Nelson and Lawrence J. White
-
Antitrust Policy During the Clinton Administration
By Carl Shapiro and Robert E. Litan
-
"Market Definition in Monopoly Cases: A Paradigm is Missing,"
-
Has the Consumer Harm Standard Lost its Teeth?
By Howard H. Chang, David S. Evans, ...
-
Horizontal Merger Antitrust Enforcement: Some Historical Perspectives, Some Current Observations
-
Horizontal Merger Antitrust Enforcement: Some Historical Perspectives, Some Current Observations
-
Market Definition and Market Power in Payment Card Networks: Some Comments and Considerations