Comparing Judicial Compensation: Apples, Oranges, and Cherry-Picking
78 Pages Posted: 18 Mar 2008 Last revised: 24 Apr 2008
Date Written: April 20, 2008
Abstract
United States Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts describes the American judiciary as the envy of other constitutional democracies. But in one respect, the judiciary apparently trails others: judicial pay. Citing higher salaries of judges in other countries, Chief Justice Roberts and Associate Justices Stephen Breyer and Samuel Alito have all argued that inadequate judicial pay leads to a decline in judicial performance and quality.
Judicial pay advocates apparently make these comparisons to emphasize that low judicial salaries threaten judicial quality and independence or, alternatively, that high judicial salaries ensure quality and independence. But the argument is incomplete, relying upon several unsubstantiated assumptions. This Article notes these assumptions, asks whether they are correct and, consequently, whether the international comparisons actually reveal an underpayment of U.S. federal judges. The comparative argument seems a useful avenue for inquiry into whether increases in salary will produce increases in judicial quality. But, as this Article shows, the institutional and societal differences among countries means isolated comparisons to foreign judiciaries raise more questions than answers in the judicial pay debate.
Keywords: judicial pay, judicial behavior, salary, compensation, efficiency wages, supreme courts, high courts, international comparison
JEL Classification: J18, J30, J32, J38, J45, J68, K00, L32, M52, P52
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
By Stephen B. Bright and Patrick Keenan
-
Judicial Independence and Minority Interests
By Daniel Berkowitz, Chris W. Bonneau, ...
-
Are Judges Overpaid?: A Skeptical Response to the Judicial Salary Debate
By Stephen J. Choi, Mitu Gulati, ...
-
"Additional Evidence" under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act: The Need for Rigor
By Andrey Krahmal, Perry Zirkel, ...
-
Space, Place and Speech: The Expressive Topography
By Timothy Zick
-
Space, Place and Speech: The Expressive Topography
By Timothy Zick
-
Elitism, Expediency and the New Certiorari: Requiem for the Learned Hand Tradition
-
Judicial Compensation and the Definition of Judicial Power in the Early Republic
-
Judicial Independence and Retention Elections
By Brandice Canes-wrone, Tom S. Clark, ...