Comparing Models of Corporate Bankruptcy Prediction: Distance to Default vs. Z-Score
21 Pages Posted: 26 Aug 2009 Last revised: 10 Nov 2009
Date Written: July 1, 2009
Abstract
This paper examines the performance of two commonly applied bankruptcy prediction models, the accounting ratio-based Altman Z-Score model, and the structural Distance to Default model which currently underlies Morningstar’s Financial Health Grade for public companies (Morningstar 2008). Specifically, we tested the following:
1. The ordinal ability of each model to distinguish companies most likely to file for bankruptcy from those least likely to file for bankruptcy as measured by the Accuracy Ratio 2. The cardinal ability of each model to predict bankruptcy as measured by the bankruptcy rate of healthy-scored companies and the average rating before bankruptcy 3. The decay of the ordinal performance of each model over time as measured by the cumulative percentage change in Ordinal Score 4. The stability of the ratings of each model as measured by the Weighted Average Drift Distance
We are cognizant that the Z-Score was not intended to be used on non-manufacturing companies (Altman 2002). However, in practice we find it is commonly used to gauge the financial health of all companies. For our purposes, we found it more relevant to include we did include non-manufacturing companies in our testing universe. We found that Distance to Default has superior ordinal and cardinal bankruptcy prediction power within our universe. It also has a more durable bankruptcy signal, but it generates less stable ratings than the Z-Score.
Keywords: Distance to Default, Z-Score, Altman, Morningstar
JEL Classification: G10, G11, G12, G31, G32, G33
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Parameterizing Credit Risk Models with Rating Data
By Mark Hrycay and Mark Carey
-
The Role of Non-Financial Factors in Internal Credit Ratings
By Jens Grunert, Lars Norden, ...
-
The Role of Non-Financial Factors on Internal Credit Ratings
By Jens Grunert, Lars Norden, ...
-
Issues in the Credit Risk Modeling of Retail Markets
By Linda Allen and Gayle L. Delong
-
Modeling Credit Risk for Smes: Evidence from the Us Market
By Edward I. Altman and Gabriele Sabato
-
Effects of the New Basel Capital Accord on Bank Capital Requirement for SMEs
By Edward I. Altman and Gabriele Sabato
-
Riskcalc for Private Companies: Moody's Default Model
By Eric G. Falkenstein, Andrew Boral, ...