Talking is Worthwhile: The Role of Employee Voice in Protecting, Enhancing, and Encouraging Individual Rights to Job Security in a Collective System

41 Pages Posted: 25 Feb 2010

See all articles by Anne Marie Lofaso

Anne Marie Lofaso

West Virginia University - College of Law

Date Written: February 24, 2010

Abstract

In this tribute to Clyde Summers - my teacher, my mentor, and my former employer - I use notes that I took during labor law class (in the spring semester 1989) and also draw upon memories of our numerous conversations to show the extent to which Professor Summers influenced my thinking about job security. “Talking is worthwhile” - or so preached Summers. Using that idea as my springboard, I trace the various incarnations of the law’s treatment of job security in circumstances of economic distress. In addition to providing unemployment or other post-termination benefits, I demonstrate that the law can have various pre-termination roles that range from least to most cooperative between the parties. These roles include the following: do nothing to notify workers of an impending layoff to furnish workers with information relevant to an impending layoff to compel employers to consult or bargain with employees’ representatives with a view to(ward) reaching agreement to compel the parties to co-decide what to do in these situations. After comparing United States federal law (which in many cases mandates advance notification, information exchange, effects bargaining, and sometimes even bargaining) with the European Union’s collective redundancies directive (which compels pre-decisional consultation among the parties with a view to reaching agreement), I reason why “talking [before the layoff] is worthwhile.” I conclude by showing how my preferred solution - to extend mandatory, pre-decisional bargaining (or at least consultation) over mass layoffs and plant closings to nonunionized workers - effectuates national labor policy as Professor Summers understood it. My simple solution - to give employees voice - also empowers workers to take control of their destinies by helping them to save their jobs and the businesses that employ them when both worker and firm are most vulnerable. Accordingly, my solution both dignifies workers and encourages them to become autonomous agents of their working lives - foundational values in a human-rights approach to labor and employment law.

Suggested Citation

Lofaso, Anne Marie, Talking is Worthwhile: The Role of Employee Voice in Protecting, Enhancing, and Encouraging Individual Rights to Job Security in a Collective System (February 24, 2010). Employee Rights and Employment Policy Journal, Vol. 14, No. 1, 2010, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1558563

Anne Marie Lofaso (Contact Author)

West Virginia University - College of Law ( email )

PO Box 6130
101 Law Center Drive
Morgantown, WV 26506-6130
United States
304-293-7356 (Phone)
304-293-6891 (Fax)

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
250
Abstract Views
2,030
Rank
222,467
PlumX Metrics