The Article II Safeguards of Federal Jurisdiction

69 Pages Posted: 24 Mar 2011 Last revised: 24 Mar 2012

See all articles by Tara Leigh Grove

Tara Leigh Grove

University of Texas School of Law

Date Written: March 18, 2011

Abstract

Jurisdiction stripping has long been treated as a battle between Congress and the federal judiciary. Scholars have thus overlooked the important (and surprising) role that the executive branch has played in these jurisdictional struggles. I seek to fill that void. Drawing on two strands of social science research, I argue that the executive branch has a strong incentive to use its constitutional authority over the enactment and enforcement of federal law to oppose jurisdiction-stripping measures. Notably, this structural argument has considerable historical support. The executive branch has repeatedly opposed jurisdiction-stripping proposals in Congress. That has been true even when the President was otherwise deeply critical of the federal courts’ constitutional jurisprudence (such as during the Franklin Roosevelt and Reagan Administrations). Furthermore, even when jurisdiction-stripping measures do become law, the executive branch controls the enforcement of that law. The Department of Justice has repeatedly used this enforcement authority to urge the courts to interpret jurisdictional restrictions narrowly in order to preserve jurisdiction over constitutional claims. This executive branch practice has important implications for the Obama Justice Department, as it litigates cases brought by current and former detainees in the war on terror. One provision of the Military Commissions Act of 2006 appears to preclude any court from examining a detainee’s challenge to his “conditions of confinement” during his detention. The executive branch could substantially limit the impact of this law by conceding (as it has in prior administrations) that the federal courts retain jurisdiction over constitutional claims.

Keywords: federal courts, constitutional law, jurisdiction stripping, executive branch

Suggested Citation

Grove, Tara Leigh, The Article II Safeguards of Federal Jurisdiction (March 18, 2011). Columbia Law Review, Vol. 112, 2012, FSU College of Law, Public Law Research Paper No. 489, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1789899

Tara Leigh Grove (Contact Author)

University of Texas School of Law ( email )

727 East Dean Keeton Street
Austin, TX 78705
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
242
Abstract Views
1,811
Rank
229,730
PlumX Metrics