The Gross Confusion Deep in the Heart of Univ. of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar

4 California Law Review Circuit 75 (2013)

9 Pages Posted: 1 Apr 2013 Last revised: 10 Jun 2013

See all articles by Brian S. Clarke

Brian S. Clarke

University of South Carolina - Joseph F. Rice School of Law; Washington & Lee University School of Law; Charlotte School of Law; Western Carolina University - College of Business

Date Written: March 21, 2013

Abstract

This essay addresses a fundamental issue underlying the Supreme Court’s consideration of Univ. of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar, namely the parameters of the factual causation standard applicable in disparate treatment cases. This essay also addresses a previously unrecognized area of agreement between the plurality and dissent in Price Waterhouse v. Hopkins that can resolve the factual causation issue underlying Nassar.

The Court’s most recent pronouncement on this issue, in Gross v. FBL Financial Services, has led to confusion as defendants and courts have interpreted Gross to require sole factual causation for the plaintiff to prevail. Yet, sole causation is inherently absurd as every occurrence has a virtually infinite number of factual causes. Nassar provides the Court with a golden opportunity to eliminate the causal confusion that followed Gross and replace it with causal coherence.

To do so, this essay argues, the Court should explicitly adopt the unrecognized factual causation standard from Price Waterhouse: that but-for causation in the disparate treatment context is established when the employer’s consideration of a protected trait was a necessary element of the set of factors that caused the decision.

Keywords: Causation, Cause In Fact, Factual Causation, Ness, Gross, Nassar, Price Waterhouse, But For, But-For

Suggested Citation

Clarke, Brian S., The Gross Confusion Deep in the Heart of Univ. of Texas S.W. Med. Center v. Nassar (March 21, 2013). 4 California Law Review Circuit 75 (2013), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2242046 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2242046

Brian S. Clarke (Contact Author)

University of South Carolina - Joseph F. Rice School of Law ( email )

1525 Senate Street
Columbia, SC 29208
United States

Washington & Lee University School of Law

Lexington, VA 24450
United States

Charlotte School of Law

2145 Suttle Avenue
Charlotte, NC 28208
United States

Western Carolina University - College of Business

Forsyth Hall 122G
Cullowhee, NC 28723
United States
828.227.7412 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.wcu.edu/learn/departments-schools-colleges/cob/

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
133
Abstract Views
1,103
Rank
388,166
PlumX Metrics