Privatization of Social Security: Lessons from Chile
31 Pages Posted: 16 Jul 2000 Last revised: 30 Oct 2022
Date Written: October 1993
Abstract
In Chile, all covered workers must place 10% of monthly earnings in a savings account with a highly regulated intermediary that manages a single fund and provides survivors and disability insurance. Workers pay a commission charge, in addition to the mandatory 10%, to finance this insurance and to cover the costs and profits of the intermediaries. On becoming eligible to receive benefits, a worker can choose between a sequence of phased withdrawals and a real annuity. In addition, there is a sizable guaranteed minimum pension. Unlike the purchased annuities, the minimum pension is not indexed, but adjusted by the government from time to time. The Chilean reform gets high marks for defending the system from political risk and for its effects on capital accumulation and on the functioning of the capital market. The Chilean reform gets low marks for the provision of insurance and for administrative cost. Perhaps the most surprising aspect of the Chilean reform is the high cost of running a privatized social security system, higher than the 'inefficient' system that it replaced. Valdes-Prieto has estimated that the average administrative charge per effective affiliate while active is U.S. $89.10 per year (for 1991) which is 2.94% of average taxable earnings. This is close to 30% of the 10% mandatory savings rate. The cost per person is not far from costs observed in other privately-managed pension systems, such as defined- benefit private pensions in the U.S. However, it compares unfavorably with administrative costs in well-run unified government managed systems. The issue here is the administrative efficiency of reliance
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Rethinking Public Pension Reform Initiatives
By Peter Heller
-
Pension Developments and Reforms in Transition Economies
By Marco Cangiano, Carlo Cottarelli, ...
-
From Generosity to Sustainability: The Austrian Pension System and Options for its Reform
By Manfred Koch and Christian Thimann
-
Investing U.S. Social Security Trust Fund Assets in Private Securities
-
Increasing Dependency Ratios, Pensions, and Tax Smoothing
By Efraim Sadka and Vito Tanzi