Quibbling Siblings: Conflicts between Trademarks and Geographical Indications
46 Pages Posted: 18 Jul 2007
Abstract
The relationship between Trademarks and Geographical Indications (GIs) has historically been tempestuous. Each of these quibbling siblings, members of the broader family of Unfair Competition law, entitles registrants to the exclusive use of a sign. So what happens when a GI collective and a trademark proprietor lay claim to the same sign within a single jurisdiction? As part of the renewed interest in TRIPs flexibilities and attempts at accommodating or reconciling differences between national laws, this paper explores a newly emerging space that may just be big enough for the both of them. The analysis draws on a recent World Trade Organization (WTO) Panel Report, which identifies the legal foundations for cohabitation. The Report coincides with doctrinal developments at the national and regional level which initially identified this zone of compromise: the geographical 'descriptive use' defence in trademark law. Coexistence is significant as it alters the dynamic of a venerable conflict between trademark and GI regimes, which has been locked in the language of trumps for several decades. Accordingly, this paper introduces the players and describes the game of one-upmanship prior to this development in Part I; outlines the WTO decision in Part II and then draws parallels with doctrinal developments in the EU and US which presaged the possibility of coexistence in Part III. It concludes with an endorsement of coexistence as an equitable solution.
Keywords: trademark, geographical indications, TRIPs, conflict, intellectual property
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Conflict and Complementarity in Trade, Cultural Diversity and Intellectual Property Rights
By Tomer Broude
-
Conflict and Complementarity in Trade, Cultural Diversity and Intellectual Property Rights
By Tomer Broude
-
Melton Mowbray and the Gi Pie in the Sky: Exploring Cartographies of Protection
-
Geographic Trademarks and the Protection of Competitor Communication
-
Traditional Knowledge and Geographical Indications: Foundations, Interests and Negotiating Positions
By Marion Panizzon and Thomas Cottier
-
Conflicts between U.S. Law and International Treaties Concerning Geographical Indications
-
A Study of the Basmati Case (India-US Basmati Rice Dispute): The Geographical Indication Perspective