Using a Dual-Sourcing Option in the Presence of Asymmetric Information about Supplier Reliability: Competition vs. Diversification
37 Pages Posted: 29 Sep 2008 Last revised: 3 Apr 2012
Date Written: September 5, 2011
Abstract
We study a buyer’s strategic use of a dual-sourcing option when facing suppliers possessing private information about their disruption likelihood. We solve for the buyer’s optimal procurement contract. We show that the optimal contract can be interpreted as the buyer choosing between diversification and competition benefits. Better information increases diversification benefits and decreases competition benefits. Therefore, with better information the buyer is more inclined to diversify. Moreover, better information may increase or decrease the value of the dual-sourcing option, depending on the buyer’s unit revenue: for large revenue, the buyer uses the dual sourcing option for diversification, the benefits of which increase with information; for small revenue, the buyer uses the dual sourcing option for competition, the benefits of which decrease with information. Surprisingly, as the reliability of the entire supply base decreases, the buyer may stop diversifying under asymmetric information (to leverage competition), while it would never do so under symmetric information. Finally, we analyze the effect of codependence between supply disruptions. We find that lower codependence leads the buyer to rely less on competition. Because competition keeps the information costs in check, a reduction in supplier codependence increases the buyer’s value of information. Therefore, strategic actions to reduce codependence between supplier disruptions should not be seen as a substitute for learning about suppliers’ reliabilities.
Keywords: Supply Risk, Mechanism Design, Diversification
JEL Classification: L15, C72, D24, D82
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Supply Disruptions, Asymmetric Information and a Backup Production Option
By Zhibin (ben) Yang, Goker Aydin, ...
-
Independence of Capacity Ordering and Financial Subsidies to Risky Suppliers
-
Risk, Financing and the Optimal Number of Suppliers
By Volodymyr Babich, Goker Aydin, ...
-
Total-Cost Procurement Auctions: Should the Buyer Reveal Suppliers' Quality?
By Dimitris Kostamis, Damian R. Beil, ...
-
Decentralized Supply Risk Management
By Goker Aydin, Volodymyr Babich, ...
-
Supply Side Story: Risks, Guarantees, Competition and Information Asymmetry
By Mehmet Gumus, Saibal Ray, ...
-
Bargaining Power and Supply Base Diversification
By Zhixi Wan and Damian R. Beil
-
Manufacturers' Competition and Subsidies to Suppliers
By Adam A. Wadecki, Volodymyr Babich, ...
-
By Shrutivandana Sharma, Volodymyr Babich, ...
-
Contracting with Asymmetric Demand Information in Supply Chains
By Volodymyr Babich, Hantao Li, ...