In Search of the 'Vertical': An Exploration of What Makes International Criminal Tribunals Different (and Why)
McGill University - Faculty of Law
October 9, 2008
International criminal tribunals have often claimed that they are in a 'vertical' relationship vis-a-vis states that is fundamentally different from 'horizontal' international criminal law, as exists between states. Although there are many studies of specific aspects of that claim to verticality (for example, the power to order subponea), there have few attempts to systematically study all the possible ways in which international criminal tribunals could be described as being distinctly 'vertical'. More importantly, international criminal justice still lacks a comprehensive theory of what it is that allows international criminal tribunals to claim 'verticality'.
This chapter seeks to remedy these shortcomings. It argues that 'verticality' is truly the defining feature of the tribunals as institutions of international criminal justice, not only for the purposes of analyzing cooperation, but also to understand complex issues of jurisdiction. The chapter also develops a theory of the foundations of verticality, by arguing that it is only tenuously anchored in the law, and should be understood more broadly as an affirmation of international criminal tribunals' separate identity. That identity is indissociable from international criminal justice's claim to emancipate itself from the inter-state world.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 57
Keywords: international criminal justice, international criminal tribunals, yugoslavia, rwanda, sierra leone, international criminal court, international criminal law, human rights, international organizations, exception, vertical, horizontal, judicial assistance, extradition, transfer, abduction, immunities
JEL Classification: K33working papers series
Date posted: October 14, 2008 ; Last revised: October 30, 2008
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo7 in 0.235 seconds