University of Pennsylvania Law School; Bar Ilan University - Faculty of Law
Yeshiva University - Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
Northwestern University Law Review, Vol. 103, Pg. 1823, 2009
U of Penn, Inst for Law & Econ Research Paper No. 09-02
This Essay addresses an anomaly in trespass law. Trespass law is generally understood as the paradigmatic example of property-rule protection: an owner can obtain an injunction against the trespasser and have him removed from her land. The property-rule protection enjoyed by the owner protects her right to exclude others and to set the price for the use of her property. However, the property-rule protection only exists ex ante: it avails only against imminent or ongoing trespasses. Ex post, after a trespass ends, the owner can only recover compensation measured by the market value of the unauthorized use, i.e., the going rent. This liability-rule compensation dilutes the ex ante property-rule protection of ownership. Effectively, it grants trespassers a call option on others' property, creating a mismatch between rights and remedies.
To remedy this mismatch, we introduce the concept of propertized compensation - a damage measure that sets compensation equal to the owner's pre-trespass asking price. We contend that propertized compensation should become the primary remedial option in trespass cases. The use of this measure will reinstate the owner's position as a price maker, entitling her to recover the amount that she would have agreed to accept ex ante in a voluntary exchange. We further argue that owners who cannot produce evidence regarding their pre-trespass asking price (as well as owners who prefer not to seek propertized compensation) should be entitled to seek disgorgement of the trespasser's profits. Finally, we claim, contra the extant regime, that market-value compensation should only be used in the exceptional cases of trespass by necessity, media trespass, and good faith encroachments. In all other cases, it should only be awarded if the owners specifically ask for it.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 40
Keywords: Property law, property-rule protection, ongoing trespasses, imminent trespassing, disgorgement of profits, market-value compensation, trespass by necessity, media trespass, good faith encroachment, rights and remedies, evidence, evidence law, cheap talk, credible signaling, propertized compensation
JEL Classification: K11, K42Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: January 21, 2009 ; Last revised: March 10, 2010
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.328 seconds