A Second Look at Special Close Corporation Legislation
Dennis S. Karjala
Arizona State University College of Law
Texas Law Review, Vol. 58, p. 1207, 1980
Fifty years have passed since commentators first called for special legislation designed to meet the problems of close corporations. Statutory results vary considerably. This Article critically analyzes these approaches and argues that a modem general incorporation statute, rather than a close corporation law supposedly tailored to its special needs, better serves the close corporation. Not only have legislators not yet drafted the right close corporation law, the entire endeavor displays fatal conceptual flaws and should be abandoned.
The North Carolina approach is the less ambitious and merely includes in its general incorporation law a section recognizing the validity of unanimous written shareholder agreements. This approach, however, is unlikely to supply any additional benefits in a jurisdiction that otherwise adopts the flexible approach of the Model Act.
The Delaware approach grants these corporations special treatment, either in sections scattered throughout the general law but applicable only to the defined close corporation, or in the more integrated form of a separate act or division of the general law. This approach to the resolution of close corporation problems is fundamentally misconceived because special legislation, however, is unnecessary. Most of the problems it seeks to solve result from the rigid interpretations courts once gave to corporation statutes, but the flexibility of modem statutes has cured this rigidity. To the extent that statutory problems remain, the best solution lies in legislation specially designed to meet the perceived problem rather than in wholesale rewriting of the corporate law applicable to small businesses.
A third approach to the resolution of close corporation problems is reflected in the Model Business Corporation Act I. It, as amended in, is sufficiently flexible to meet the needs of small businesses without additional legislation aimed specifically at close corporations. This permits all corporations as much contractual freedom as is consistent with public policy, best meets the needs of small businesses.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 62
Keywords: Close Corporations, Model Business Corporation Act, Corporate Law
Date posted: May 29, 2009
© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo5 in 0.312 seconds