When Acquisition Spoils Retention: Selling Direct vs. Delegation under CRM

Abstract:     
The widespread implementation of customer relationship management (CRM) technologies in business has allowed companies to increasingly focus on both acquiring and retaining customers. The challenge of designing incentive mechanisms that simultaneously focus on customer acquisition and customer retention comes from the fact that customer acquisition and customer retention are usually separate but intertwined tasks that make providing proper incentives more difficult. The present study develops incentive mechanisms that simultaneously address acquisition and retention of customers with an emphasis on the interactions between them. The main focus of this study is to examine the impact of the negative effect of acquisition on retention, i.e., the spoiling effect, on firm performance under direct selling and delegation of customer acquisition.

Our main finding is that the negative effect of acquisition on retention has a significant impact on acquisition and retention efforts and firm profit. In particular, when customer acquisition and retention are independent, the firm’s profit is higher under direct selling than under delegation; however, when acquisition spoils retention, interestingly, the firm’s profit may be higher under delegation. Our analysis also finds that the spoiling effect not only reduces the optimal acquisition effort but may also reduce retention effort under both direct selling and delegation. Comparing the optimal efforts under direct selling and delegation, the acquisition effort is always lower under delegation regardless of the spoiling effect, but the retention effort may be higher under delegation with the spoiling effect. Furthermore, when customer antagonism effect from price promotions is considered, our main results hold regarding the firm’s preferences between direct selling and delegation, which demonstrates the robustness of our model.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 34

Keywords: customer acquisition, customer retention, customer value, customer relationship management, incentive mechanism

JEL Classification: D01, D23, D86, J53, L14, M14, M31, M54

Accepted Paper Series