Analyzing the Role for a Consumer Financial Protection Agency
Networks Financial Institute Policy Brief 2009-PB-13, December 2009
23 Pages Posted: 20 Dec 2009
Date Written: December 1, 2009
Abstract
In the debate over the proposed establishment of a new Consumer Financial Protection Agency, much attention has been given to discussion of whether consumers are irrational or incompetent and therefore need paternalistic regulators to look after them, and whether inadequate consumer protection regulation was a contributor to the financial crisis. Arguments over these questions are misplaced. Consumer protection regulation is commonplace in financial markets, and is essential even where consumers are fully rational and financial crises are distant. The potential role for a CFPA should first be examined based on consideration of the benefits and shortcomings of current consumer protection regulation, and how a dedicated consumer protection regulator would be likely to change things. Specific details of proposed legislation that affect the structure and authority of a CFPA should be evaluated separately rather than being used to determine whether such an agency is a good idea or a bad one. Consideration of the general principles for and against establishment of an independent CFPA may help to illuminate the strengths and weaknesses of specific legislative proposals.
Keywords: banking, regulation, consumer protection, consumer financial protection agency
JEL Classification: G28, K23
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Allocation of Governmental Regulatory Authority: Federalism and the Case of Insurance Regulation
-
State Regulation and Consumer Protection in the Insurance Industry
-
Consuming Debt: Structuring the Federal Response to Abuses in Consumer Credit
-
A Pragmatic Approach to the Phased Consolidation of Financial Regulation in the United States
-
Three Problematic Truths About the Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act of 2009
By Joshua D. Wright and Todd J. Zywicki
-
Keeping Both Eyes Wide Open: The Life of a Competition Authority Among Sectoral Regulators
By Pedro P. Barros, Steffen Hoernig, ...