'No Salvation Outside Islam': Muslim Modernists, Democratic Politics, and Islamic Theological Exclusivism
University of Toronto - Faculty of Law
November 21, 2010
The extent to which religions with excluvist claims of salvation can be tolerated in a democracy has been the subject of substantial controversy among liberal political theorists, as exemplified in the different positions taken on this question by Jean-Jacques Rousseau in The Social Contract and John Rawls in A Theory of Justice. This article explores the plausibility of Rawls' claim that democratic institutions have the tendency to dilute the exclusivist claims of salvation theologies in the context of Muslim Modernist theologians in 20th century Egypt. While these theologians were not living in a proper liberal democracy, the prospect of just terms of coexistence with non-Muslim, particularly western, powers apparently prompted them to undertake a substantial revision of pre-modern Muslim theology with respect to the prospects of salvation for non-Muslims. Rejecting pre-modern theologians' insistence on acceptance of true doctrine as a pre-condition for salvation, these modernist theologians radically expanded the concept of excuse while at the same time effectively eliminating the pre-modern doctrine of the duty of inquiry with the result that non-Muslims' prospects for salvation became almost entirely a function of their practical virtue, i.e., contribution to the welfare of mankind and their readiness to engage in peaceful relations with Muslims. The example of these theologians, at least, suggest Rawls' intutions on the effects of democracy on exclusivist theology are more plausible than Rousseau's concerns that exclusivist theology will subvert liberal democracy.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 37
Keywords: salvation, excuse, Islamic theology, Muslim modernism, democracy, practical virtue, theoretical virtueworking papers series
Date posted: November 22, 2010
© 2013 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo2 in 0.343 seconds