Rethinking Discrimination Law
University of Cincinnati College of Law
February 1, 2011
Michigan Law Review, Forthcoming
Temple University Legal Studies Research Paper 2011-5
In the 1970s, federal courts began identifying categories of discrimination, such as disparate impact, disparate treatment and harassment. They then created elaborate, multi-part rubrics tied to each category. Modern employment discrimination law is defined by these frameworks. They serve as gatekeepers that control the substantive discrimination narratives juries hear and also structure the ways that judges and litigants think about discrimination.
Legal scholarship is replete with excellent articles challenging specific frameworks courts use to evaluate discrimination claims. This Article does not challenge any particular framework. Instead it challenges whether courts should even use frameworks to conceptualize discrimination in the first place. It argues that just as faulty sorting contributes to stereotyping and societal discrimination, courts are using faulty structures to substantively limit discrimination claims.
The Article makes three central contributions. First, it demonstrates how discrimination analysis has been reduced to a rote sorting process. It recognizes and makes explicit the courts’ methodology so that the structure and its effects can be examined. Second, it demonstrates how the frameworks tend to squeeze out claims that are arguably cognizable under the federal discrimination statutes’ broad operative language. The Article’s final contribution is to propose a simpler model for thinking about employment discrimination law. It argues for a return to first principles that requires the courts to specifically define key statutory language.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 64
Keywords: Title VII, ADEA, ADA, Statutory Interpretation, Statutory Construction, Frameworks, Proof Structures
JEL Classification: K31, K39Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: February 12, 2011 ; Last revised: March 16, 2011
© 2013 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo4 in 0.375 seconds