The Rule of Text: Is it Possible to Govern Using (Only) Statutes?

Peter Tiersma

Loyola Law School Los Angeles

March 9, 2011

NYU Journal of Law & Liberty, Forthcoming
Loyola-LA Legal Studies Paper No. 2011-11

This essay explores whether it is possible to govern solely by means of written text, with little or no interpretive discretion allowed to judges. The rule of text, as we might refer to this concept, appears to be a goal that textualist judges are hoping to achieve. The essay first reviews the attractions of written law, which came into being not long after writing was invented. Yet it was only in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries that rulers like Frederick the Great of Prussia and later the French revolutionaries tried to govern their nations by means of comprehensive codes of law, which judges were forbidden to interpret. Those efforts to implement a pure form of the rule of text largely failed. Next, we consider several U.S. Supreme Court cases that involved interpretive questions. Could the problems have been avoided by more careful drafting? I conclude that mistakes and ambiguities can in principle be prevented at the drafting stage or be solved by means of amendment after they are discovered, but that vagueness is a far more difficult problem. To the extent that the rule of text demands that judges not interpret, they would have to refer statutory uncertainties to the legislature. Both the Prussians and the French had a procedure of this kind, sometimes known as référé legislatif. Asking the legislature to interpret statutes ultimately proved impractical. Although to some extent it violates the separation of powers, there seems to be no feasible alternative to giving judges the authority to resolve the uncertainties that inevitably arise in written text.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 28

Download This Paper

Date posted: March 10, 2011  

Suggested Citation

Tiersma, Peter, The Rule of Text: Is it Possible to Govern Using (Only) Statutes? (March 9, 2011). NYU Journal of Law & Liberty, Forthcoming; Loyola-LA Legal Studies Paper No. 2011-11. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1782130

Contact Information

Peter M. Tiersma (Contact Author)
Loyola Law School Los Angeles ( email )
919 Albany Street
Los Angeles, CA 90015-1211
United States
213-736-1162 (Phone)
213-380-3769 (Fax)
HOME PAGE: www.tiersma.com
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 884
Downloads: 200
Download Rank: 94,632

© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.  FAQ   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Copyright   Contact Us
This page was processed by apollo7 in 0.250 seconds