Management Renewal? Consequences of the Current Evolutions of the 'Best Interests of the Corporation' in North American and French Corporate Law
Université Laval - Faculty of law; University of Nantes - Faculty of Law and Political Science
March 31, 2011
The concept of the stakeholder can be integrated into corporate law through a broad interpretation of the idea of the best interests of the corporation. In this paper, I address criticisms of the classic definition of the principal purpose of a firm. Even if U.S. law is less interventionist and more ambiguous than French law in this domain, it is still possible to put forward a broad interpretation of the best interests of the corporation for the USA. The interests of Canadian and French firms include their stakeholders. While the notion of corporation interest is debatable in France, Canada has recently modified its stance regarding the purpose of the firm. Besides recent decision BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, the decision of the Canadian Supreme Court Magasins à rayons Peoples Inc. (Syndic de) v. Wise in 2004 was a crucial step in the "best interests of the corporation" definition. With respect to fiduciary duties, this ruling set aside the traditional interpretation of the "best interests of the corporation" which gives primacy to shareholders' interests. The Court held that the expression "best interests of the corporation" refers to the maximization of the corporation's value. This innovative vision of the best interest of the corporation introduces stakeholder theory and corporate social responsibility (CSR) into corporate law and provides a new frame for management responsibilities. The legal system imposes in fine on the managers to orient their corporations in socially behavior way and to exercise their power on behalf of the corporation's constituents: shareholders, workers, suppliers and communities in which these corporations thrive. As a result, this paper concludes with an extended discussion of the implications for the future of research in management, corporate law, economics and finance.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 24
Keywords: Corporate Law, Best Interests of the corporation, Comparative Analysis, Corporate Social Responsibility, Implications for Management
JEL Classification: G30, K22, M14
Date posted: April 17, 2011
© 2016 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollobot1 in 2.454 seconds