How Do Agency Costs Affect Firm Value? Evidence from China

Abstract:     
Using newly available data, we examine the effects of the agency conflicts between ultimate controlling shareholders and minority shareholders in China’s publicly listed firms between 2004 and 2009. We measure the severity of these agency problems by the excess control rights of the ultimate controlling shareholders. We show that higher excess control rights are associated with significantly lower firm value. We identify two channels through which the excess control rights affect firm value: (1) related-party loan guarantees, and (2) legal violations. We find that higher excess control rights are associated with significantly larger amounts of related-party loan guarantees (scaled by assets) for non-state and private firms, but not for state-owned firms. We find that, for non-state and private firms, the excess controls rights are associated with (1) significantly higher probability that the firm will issue value-destroying related-party loan guarantees and (2) significantly worse stock market reactions the announcements of related-party loan guarantees. However, these results do not hold for state-owned firms. We also find that higher excess control rights are associated with significantly higher probability, frequency and severity of legal violations for non-state and private firms, but not for state-owned firms.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 40

Keywords: Corporate governance, ultimate control, agency costs, connected party transactions, fraud, firm value

JEL Classification: G32, G34

working papers series