Why It's Called the Affordable Care Act
University of Michigan Law School
Jill R. Horwitz
UCLA School of Law; National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER)
August 19, 2011
Michigan Law Review First Impressions, Vol. 110, p. 1, 2011
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (“ACA”) requires most Americans to obtain health insurance for themselves and their dependents by 2014. In a recent essay, Professor Douglas Kahn and Professor Jeffrey Kahn take issue with one of several justifications for what has become the “individual mandate”: that it solves the free-rider problem that arises when an uninsured individual receives care without paying for it, thus forcing providers to raise costs for paying (typically insured) patients. Kahn and Kahn claim that the free-rider problem has been exaggerated. Even if it were a meaningful problem, they argue, the ACA only resolves it by shifting the burden of uncompensated care from insured patients to taxpayers, thus substituting one type of free riding for another. Finally, they suggest that the free-rider trope hijacked the political debate and distracted from the ACA’s redistributive consequences.
These claims are unconvincing. Kahn and Kahn can maintain that the free-rider problem has been exaggerated only because they define “free rider” to mean something it does not. Although their claim that the ACA substitutes provider-subsidized free riding for taxpayer-subsidized insurance is accurate, Kahn and Kahn fail to appreciate the overwhelming strength of the latter approach. And their belief that the free-rider argument somehow prevented debate about the ACA’s distributional consequences is, as an empirical matter, simply false. More fundamentally, Kahn and Kahn never acknowledge that achieving near-universal coverage through the private market depends on redistribution through community rating. The ACA’s redistribution is thus tied up with questions relating to the level of risk-rating that is acceptable in a decent society, the purpose of health insurance, and the moral urgency of covering the uninsured.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 9
Keywords: Affordable Care Act, individual mandate, community rating, free rider, redistribution
JEL Classification: H50, H51, I10, I11, I18, K00Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: August 19, 2011 ; Last revised: January 9, 2012
© 2013 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo6 in 0.375 seconds