Abstract

http://ssrn.com/abstract=1938454
 


 



Religious Freedom, Church-State Separation, and the Ministerial Exception


Richard W. Garnett


Notre Dame Law School

Thomas C. Berg


University of St. Thomas, St. Paul/Minneapolis, MN - School of Law

Kimberlee W. Colby


affiliation not provided to SSRN

Carl H. Esbeck


University of Missouri School of Law

October 4, 2011

Northwestern University Law Review Colloquy, Vol. 106, p. 175, 2011
Notre Dame Legal Studies Paper No. 11-38
University of Missouri School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2011-21

Abstract:     
The Hosanna-Tabor case concerns the separation of church and state, an arrangement that is often misunderstood but is nevertheless a critical dimension of the freedom of religion protected by the First Amendment to our Constitution. For nearly a thousand years, the tradition of Western constitutionalism - the project of protecting political freedom by marking boundaries to the power of government - has been assisted by the principled commitment to religious liberty and to church-state separation, correctly understood. A community that respects - as ours does - both the importance of, and the distinction between, the spheres of political and religious authority is one in which the fundamental rights of all are more secure. A government that acknowledges this distinction, and the limits to its own reach, is one that will more consistently protect and vindicate the liberties of both individuals and institutions.

The “ministerial exception,” at issue in Hosanna-Tabor, is a clear and crucial implication of religious liberty, church autonomy, and the separation of church and state. Because any worthwhile account of religious freedom would respect the authority of religious communities to select freely their own clergy, ministers, teachers, and doctrines, any such account must include something like the ministerial-exception rule. Reasonably constructed and applied, this rule helps civil decision-makers to avoid deciding essentially religious questions. In addition, and more importantly, it protects the fundamental freedom of religious communities to educate and form their members. Although the exception may, in some cases, block lawsuits against religious institutions and communities for discrimination, it rests on the overriding and foundational premise that there are some questions the civil courts do not have the power to answer, some wrongs that a constitutional commitment to church-state separation puts beyond the law’s corrective reach. The civil authority - that is, the authority of a constitutional government - lacks “competence” to intervene in such questions, not so much because they lie beyond its technical or intellectual capacity, but because they lie beyond its jurisdiction.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 17

Keywords: Establishment Clause, religious freedom, religious liberty, separation of church and state, First Amendment, ministerial exception, Hosanna-Tabor

JEL Classification: K10, K19

Accepted Paper Series





Download This Paper

Date posted: October 4, 2011 ; Last revised: January 6, 2012

Suggested Citation

Garnett, Richard W. and Berg, Thomas C. and Colby, Kimberlee W. and Esbeck, Carl H., Religious Freedom, Church-State Separation, and the Ministerial Exception (October 4, 2011). Northwestern University Law Review Colloquy, Vol. 106, p. 175, 2011; Notre Dame Legal Studies Paper No. 11-38; University of Missouri School of Law Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2011-21 . Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1938454

Contact Information

Richard W. Garnett (Contact Author)
Notre Dame Law School ( email )
Room 327
P.O. Box 780
Notre Dame, IN 46556-0780
United States
574-631-6981 (Phone)
574-631-4197 (Fax)
Thomas Charles Berg
University of St. Thomas, St. Paul/Minneapolis, MN - School of Law ( email )
1000 La Salle Avenue
Mail # MSL400
Minneapolis, MN 55403-2015
United States

Kimberlee W. Colby
affiliation not provided to SSRN ( email )
Carl H. Esbeck
University of Missouri School of Law ( email )
Missouri Avenue & Conley Avenue
Rm. 203 John K. Hulston Hal
Columbia, MO 65211
United States
573-882-3035 (Phone)
573-882-4984 (Fax)
Feedback to SSRN


Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 1,518
Downloads: 269
Download Rank: 65,463

© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.  FAQ   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Copyright   Contact Us
This page was processed by apollo5 in 0.297 seconds