Putting Buck v. Bell in Scientific and Historical Context

Edward Larson

Pepperdine University School of Law


Pepperdine Law Review, Vol. 39, 2011
Pepperdine University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2012/4

In this article written for a law-review symposium in response to a presentation on the infamous 1927 U.S. Supreme Court opinion in Buck v. Bell, Edward J. Larson argues that, at the time that the case was decided, eugenics was on the incline, not the decline. In the 1920s, the American scientific and medical community broadly backed eugenic remedies for various forms of mental illness and retardation. Legislatures, lawyers, and jurists took their cue from this scientific and medical consensus. Absent any question that the statute at issue in Buck v. Bell was validly passed by the Virginia legislature or that due process was provided for the persons subject to its reach, the law should have withstood constitutional challenge. The tragedy of Buck v. Bell, Larson argues, was that Carrie Buck never received the due process guaranteed under Virginia’s eugenic sterilization statute and that neither her lawyers nor the courts protected her from a flagrant violation of her basic constitutional and statutory rights. Under the fact that should have been brought out at trial, Carrie Buck would not have been sterilized. More fundamentally, had due process been provided in this and other instances, while eugenics would still have been a scientific and medical mistake, it would not be a legal one.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 11

Keywords: Buck v. Bell, Eugenics, Sterilization, Due Process, Constitutional Rights, Victoria Nourse

JEL Classification: K19, K49

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: October 25, 2011  

Suggested Citation

Larson, Edward, Putting Buck v. Bell in Scientific and Historical Context (2011). Pepperdine Law Review, Vol. 39, 2011; Pepperdine University Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2012/4. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1948793

Contact Information

Edward J. Larson (Contact Author)
Pepperdine University School of Law ( email )
24255 Pacific Coast Highway
Malibu, CA 90263
United States
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 1,288
Downloads: 150
Download Rank: 147,494

© 2016 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.  FAQ   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Copyright   Contact Us
This page was processed by apollobot1 in 0.172 seconds