Mitigating Hold-Up Through Complementarities and Refunds
Jenny R. Hawkins
Case Western Reserve University, Weatherhead School of Management
September 14, 2013
Many valuable composite goods or property rights exist only by assembling multiple, monopoly-supplied components. Since a monopolist exclusively owns each component, hold-up by the last seller can result. First I design a model to show how sunk cost explains this assembly problem. Then I consider two factors that reduce sunk cost, determining conditions for which each mitigates hold-up. Specifically, I implement varied degrees of complementarities and levels of refundability of the component goods. No known previous research examines the assembly problem in terms of sunk cost or considers refunds, and little research models imperfect complementarities. I show if at least the first component purchased has stand alone value, hold-up is mitigated under any refund level. However, if only the last component purchased has stand alone value, averting hold-up depends on capacity constraints, degree of complementarities, price discrimination, and level of refund. Regardless of the degree of complementarities, full refunds prevent hold-up, while zero and partial refunds do not. Welfare analysis reveals conditions for a first or second mover advantage and when sellers endogenously choose a partial or full refund. This research offers settings when degrees of complementarity and refundability reduce sunk cost, often enough to prevent hold-up. My results also suggest policies to overcome inefficiencies in assembling property rights or component goods, such as legal requirements on full refunds, regulation on the order in which components must be purchased, and price discrimination prohibition.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 47
Keywords: anticommons, complementary monopoly, complementarities, refund, hold-up, double marginalization, property rights
JEL Classification: D4, D70, K11, K19, L1working papers series
Date posted: January 27, 2012 ; Last revised: October 20, 2013
© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo2 in 0.391 seconds