Moving Beyond Dichotomy: Comparing Composite Telecommunications Regulatory Governance Indices
Brandie Martin Nonnecke
Pennsylvania State University; University of California, Berkeley
Pennsylvania State University
March 29, 2012
Despite an apparent consensus about the importance of sound telecommunications regulatory governance, there is no agreement among researchers about how to measure it. While dichotomous coding of de jure independence has served as a proxy to measure whether an agency’s regulatory governance is transparent, non-arbitrary, and free from political influence, we view measuring multiple components of regulatory governance through an index as providing a more nuanced understanding of facilitating or inhibiting factors. This paper builds extensively upon prior research on telecommunications regulatory governance in order to compare the composite telecommunications regulatory governance indices (TRGI) available in the literature, and to construct more parsimonious indices. Using a methodology labeled “qualitative meta-synthesis” based on synthesizing previously published indices, we construct six different indices using combinations of 32 different variables, and different weights. Data from the OECD database are used to re-create the five original indices from the literature as well as our own six composites. These indices are correlated with each other, and with independent measures of regulatory governance such as the World Bank’s Government Effectiveness Index and the Rule of Law Index. The results suggest that a parsimonious index of as few as seven variables is capable of measuring the quality of telecommunications governance in a country, at the same time making the selection of variables and their weighting in the index more systematic than in previously available indices.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 20
Keywords: governance, regulation, telecommunications, telecommunications index, OECD
Date posted: April 3, 2012 ; Last revised: August 16, 2012
© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo3 in 0.422 seconds