Presidential Power and Constitutional Responsibility
Thomas P. Crocker
University of South Carolina School of Law
July 6, 2012
Boston College Law Review, Vol. 52, No. 5, 2011
Some constitutional theorists defend the existence of unbounded executive power to respond to emergencies and the inevitability of expansive discretionary powers to complete statutory directives. Against these anti-Madisonian approaches, this Article examines how the textual assignment of republican virtues helps to constitute and constrain the president’s power. The Madisonian solution for constitutional constraint both creates institutions for unenlightened statesmen and relies on virtue to make governing possible. Constitutional responsibility is a consistent textual theme found in the command to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed,” the responsibility to remain faithful to the office of president, and the obligation to preserve the Constitution itself. Although presidential discretion in executing and in interpreting the laws is inevitable, this Article explains why presidents are constrained by virtues such as care and fidelity, by integrity in interpretive practices, and by the normative and structural obligations of office. This Article contends that these Article II obligations, paired with the statutory and implied constitutional duty to do only what is both necessary and proper, provide textual grounds for thick normative constraints on presidential power even in the absence of more robust structural constraints. A president’s “necessary” power to complete statutory directives is constrained by obligations to do only what is “proper.” A president’s constitutional powers entail great responsibility both in executing the laws and in constituting the national community through constitutional practices and commitments.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 76
Keywords: Presidential Power, Constitutional Law, Necessary and Proper, Madisonian, Constitutional Structure, National Security
Date posted: July 8, 2012
© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo1 in 0.296 seconds