The Long of It: Odds That Investor Sentiment Spuriously Predicts Anomaly Returns

Abstract:     
Extremely long odds accompany the chance that spurious-regression bias accounts for investor sentiment's observed role in stock-return anomalies. We replace investor sentiment with a simulated persistent series in regressions reported by Stambaugh, Yu and Yuan (2012), who find higher long-short anomaly profits following high sentiment, due entirely to the short leg. Among 200 million simulated regressors, we find none that support those conclusions as strongly as investor sentiment. The key is consistency across anomalies. Obtaining just the predicted signs for the regression coefficients across the 11 anomalies examined in the above study occurs only once for every 43 simulated regressors.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 12

Keywords: investor sentiment, anomalies, spurious regressors

JEL Classification: G12, G14, C18

working papers series