Michael S. Pardo
University of Alabama School of Law
May 17, 2012
Alabama Law Review, Forthcoming
U of Alabama Public Law Research Paper No. 2128844
Rationality involves the power to reason appropriately, although exactly what this requires is a matter of profound disagreement. The concept of rationality features prominently in a number of academic disciplines including philosophy, economics, and psychology, as well as in law. But it does so in a variety of distinct ways and through different conceptions. In this essay, I outline three general methodological projects that rely on different conceptions of rationality: “narrow” normative, “broad” normative, and explanatory. The narrow normative project invokes the instrumental means-ends conception of rationality familiar to economic theory. The broad normative project conceives of rationality more expansively by invoking more robust notions of the means and ends of decision-making. The explanatory project, carried out in different ways in philosophy and psychology, relies on aspects of rationality to explain or interpret human behavior. In discussing these three conceptions, I also reflect on their relationships to legal theory and to legal doctrine.
This essay serves as an introduction to the Meador Lectures on Rationality held at the University of Alabama School of Law. The lectures were delivered by Rosabeth Kanter (Harvard Business School), Dean Hanoch Dagan (Tel Aviv University, Buchmann Faculty of Law), Phoebe Ellsworth (University of Michigan Law School), and Ronald J. Allen (Northwestern University School of Law).
Number of Pages in PDF File: 14
Keywords: rational, reasonable, inference, sapience, means, ends, preferences, utility, probability, bounded, heuristic, bias, standards of proof, summary judgment, sufficiency of the evidence, competence, insanity, expectations, judging, self-interest, benevolence, complexityAccepted Paper Series
Date posted: August 14, 2012
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.454 seconds