Abstract

http://ssrn.com/abstract=2128873
 
 

Footnotes (7)



 


 



Justice of the Peace?: Why Federal Rule of Evidence 404(A)(2)(C) Should Be Repealed


Colin Miller


University of South Carolina School of Law

August 13, 2012

North Carolina Law Review, Forthcoming

Abstract:     
In two 2012 opinions, Commonwealth v. Bedford and State v. Williams, courts rejected appeals by convicted homicide defendants sentenced to life imprisonment. Each defendant claimed that his victim was the first aggressor, prompting the prosecution to present character evidence concerning the victim’s character for peacefulness even though neither defendant claimed that his victim was generally a violent person. The prosecution in both cases presented this character evidence under a state counterpart to Federal Rule of Evidence 404(a)(2)(C), a frequently applied exception to the general rule that propensity character evidence is inadmissible.

Rule 404(a)(2)(C) and its state counterparts are thus the one exception to the general “Pandora’s box” theory which deems propensity character evidence inadmissible in any criminal trial unless the defendant decides to inject character evidence into trial by presenting evidence of his good character and/or evidence of the victim’s bad character. The Rule is also the rare exception to our evidentiary and constitutional framework that almost always treats criminal defendants at least as well as, and usually better than, their civil counterparts. Worst of all, this anomalous Rule treats criminal defendants worse than civil defendants in the very type of case in which the accused has the most at stake and faces the largest deployment of investigatory and prosecutorial resources. Accordingly, this article argues for the repeal of Federal Rule of Evidence 404(a)(2)(C) and state counterparts.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 48

Keywords: Character Evidence, Homicide, Self-Defense

JEL Classification: K14, K42

Accepted Paper Series


Download This Paper

Date posted: August 14, 2012 ; Last revised: September 19, 2012

Suggested Citation

Miller, Colin, Justice of the Peace?: Why Federal Rule of Evidence 404(A)(2)(C) Should Be Repealed (August 13, 2012). North Carolina Law Review, Forthcoming. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2128873 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2128873

Contact Information

Colin Miller (Contact Author)
University of South Carolina School of Law ( email )
Main & Greene Streets
Columbia, SC 29208
United States
Feedback to SSRN


Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 385
Downloads: 44
Footnotes:  7

© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.  FAQ   Terms of Use   Privacy Policy   Copyright   Contact Us
This page was processed by apollo3 in 0.328 seconds