Kelsen, the Enlightenment and Modern Premodernists
Macquarie Law School
August 23, 2012
(2012) 37 Australian Journal of Legal Philosophy 251-278
A review article on Hans Kelsen, "Secular Religion: A Polemic against the Misinterpretation of Modern Social Philosophy, Science, and Politics as 'New Religions'" (Vienna and New York, Springer, 2012). This book was written, in English, in the early 1960s, but the author withdrew it when already in proof. However, the reasons for his reluctance remain obscure and the Hans Kelsen-Institut in Vienna has decided to make the book available.
Kelsen is best known as the creator of the Pure Theory of Law, but here he barely touches on positive law. He returns to the general objections - philosophical, scientific and political - that motivated the Pure Theory. Centrally in this book, he opposes any belief in transcendence - belief in a non-material reality. He defends modernity, the acquis of the Enlightenment, against those who insist that all science must be imbued with religion. He focuses upon claims, particularly by Voegelin although many others are considered, that those who reject transcendence are themselves assuming it. Thus, it is claimed, when they attack religion, they do so surreptitiously by way of "secular" religion and so are vulnerable to their own objections - albeit that those objections are misguided in any case. Kelsen both attacks the claimants' underlying assumption of transcendence and argues that its modernist opponents are innocent of it.
Kelsen's standpoint resembles that of Popper, but Kelsen defends Marx as a scientific opponent of transcendence. However, Kelsen's conception of critical science owes less to Marx than to Freud, whose circle he had once frequented.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 30
Keywords: Kelsen, Pure Theory of Law, secular religion, transcendence, EnlightenmentAccepted Paper Series
Date posted: January 27, 2013 ; Last revised: February 12, 2013
© 2015 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.375 seconds