The Federal Tax Implications of Bush v. Gore
Paul L. Caron
Pepperdine University - School of Law
March 15, 2001
Washington University Law Quarterly, Vol. 79, p. 749, 2001
About the only thing that all of the Justices of the Supreme Court agreed upon in the recent Bush v. Gore decision was the general principle that federal courts should defer to state courts on matters of state law. As Justice Breyer put it in his dissent, the Justices only differed as to whether "this case [was] one of the few in which we may lay that fundamental principle aside." But federal courts regularly lay aside that fundamental principle in tax cases. Where the Internal Revenue Code expressly incorporates state law, federal courts in a tax proceeding frequently must decide how much weight to give to a state court ruling on state law. In 1967, the Court relied on the Erie doctrine in Commissioner v. Estate of Bosch in requiring federal courts to give "proper regard" to state court decisions. Although in theory the "proper regard" standard appears consistent with the Bush v. Gore deference principle, this Article shows that in practice the federal courts instead have given "no regard" to state court decisions in concluding in over one-half of the cases applying Bosch over the past thirty-four years that the state court judge had misapplied state law. The enormous interest generated by the Bush v. Gore decision makes this a particularly propitious time to re-visit this nettlesome question of federal tax law. The Article argues that the federal courts should return to the Erie roots of the "proper regard" test in order to give effect to the Bush v. Gore deference principle. If this approach is followed, the Bush v. Gore decision will leave a more lasting imprint in the federal tax law than in constitutional or election law.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 57
Keywords: Tax, Bush v. Gore, Erie
JEL Classification: H20, H24, H29Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: March 22, 2001
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.234 seconds