The Asset Flexibility Option and the Value of Deposit Insurance
Peter H. Ritchken
Case Western Reserve University - Department of Banking & Finance
Ramon P. DeGennaro
University of Tennessee, Knoxville - Department of Finance
James B. Thomson
University of Akron
Spot Trading LLC; Portunes LLC; Barclays Capital
Research in Finance, Vol. 13, 1995
Bank Structure and Competition: Rebuilding Banking, Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, pp. 153-176, 1991
Optimal equityholder decisions involve trade-offs between risk-minimizing strategies, which reduce the likelihood of losing the charter, and risk-maximizing strategies, which exploit the insured-deposit base. When banks cannot respond dynamically to market information, we have seen that the bank optimally selects extreme positions.
Given any flat-rate insurance scheme, incentives exist for firms to revise their portfolios dynamically in response to market information. These dynamic revisions are aimed at exploiting the insured-deposit base more fully, thereby mitigating the likelihood of bankruptcy. The additional value captured by equityholders responding dynamically to jointly maximize the charter value and the deposit insurance subsidy, beyond the static value, is captured in the value of the asset flexibility option.
In the presence of the asset flexibility option, portfolio decisions may not be extreme and interior solutions may be optimal. The likelihood of interior solutions may increase as the number of portfolio revision opportunities expands. Moreover, the value and the insured deposit base, provided at a flat rate, increases with the number of portfolio revision opportunities.
Our results suggest that the value of flat-rate deposit insurance established by static models underestimates the true value because it completely ignores the flexibility option. The impact of the flexibility option can be significant and, if ignored, may lead to understating the value of deposit insurance by as much as 40 percent. The results suggest that bank regulators should factor the flexibility option into any risk-adjusted capital guidelines and also into closure policies.
Keywords: deposit insurance, regulation, banks, options
JEL Classification: G21, G28Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: June 16, 2003
© 2013 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo3 in 0.282 seconds