Lee Anne Fennell
University of Chicago Law School
Harvard Law Review, Vol. 118, No. 5, March 2005
U Illinois Law & Economics Research Paper No. LE04-005
Legal scholars are beginning to explore how the options template, borrowed from finance, can be applied to legal problems outside the realm of finance. This article uses the options framework to add a new, intermediate entitlement form to the property rule/liability rule schema pioneered by Guido Calabresi and Douglas Melamed. Building on a fascinating but underused literature on self-assessed valuation mechanisms, I propose an entitlement form that would require entitlement-holders to create options for others (or their own future selves). These entitlements subject to self-made options or ESSMOs are capable of powerfully and elegantly addressing one of the most intractable problems in property theory - unknown subjective valuations.
By requiring a party to package her subjective valuation in the form of an option - that is, a revealing option - the ESSMO dodges the primary problems associated with property rules and liability rules while harnessing advantages of each. Like a liability rule, the ESSMO extends to other parties the right to engage in a unilateral purchase of the entitlement at an established price. Like a property rule, the ESSMO gives the entitlement holder control over the transfer price, thus protecting her idiosyncratic subjective value in the entitlement. Unlike a property rule, however, the ESSMO makes the entitlement-holder's stated valuation binding throughout an option period, and incorporates other features designed to elicit honest valuations.
The real payoff of this approach comes in complex, dynamic, multi-party commons settings. Extending my earlier work on commons and anticommons problems, I show how the ESSMO can transform environmental controls, land conservation, and aesthetic controls in private neighborhoods. I also illustrate how revealing options can address intertemporal collective action problems in institutions, as well as in individuals (such as the smoker who wishes to quit).
Number of Pages in PDF File: 90
Keywords: property rules, liability rules, options, valuation, commons, anticommonsAccepted Paper Series
Date posted: September 20, 2004
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.250 seconds