University of Illinois College of Law
Iowa Law Review, Vol. 90, p. 1747, 2005
The Constitution of the United States provides, in Article V, for its own amendment; but not every proposal for change is properly "an Amendment to this Constitution" within the meaning of Article V. Rather, there are substantive limitations on what can be accomplished as a constitutional amendment. The term amendment refers not to making any kind of change to the existing document, but to fine-tuning what is already in place. As the debates over the adoption of the Bill of Rights make clear, an amendment is not the pursuit of something new, but an intervention, shown by experience to be necessary in order to keep the Constitution on its original course. Some proposals for change so undermine the original document that they cannot be considered amendments and therefore cannot be achieved through the procedures of Article V. Any proposal to alter the Constitution through Article V requires evaluating not only the merits of the proposal, but also whether it is a proper use of the amendment process.
To say that the amendment provision of Article V is limited is not to conclude that the Constitution contains entrenched provisions that can never be changed and that it is therefore undemocratic. Americans may alter each and every provision of their Constitution, but they cannot always do so through Article V. Modifications that are more than mere amendments to the existing Constitution require higher lawmaking: the articulation of new principles by the citizenry in a period of constitutional politics, the kind that occur following a revolution or some other seismic event that alters our course going forward. One such seismic event was, of course, the Civil War, which did revisit and change the document that was ratified in 1788. The Reconstruction Amendments revised the 1788 Constitution in fundamental respects, putting in place a new and very different regime. Significantly, these changes were not achieved through the amendment procedures of Article V, and they far exceeded what could have been done through those procedures. Accordingly, the Civil War altered Article V itself, putting in place new limitations on the kinds of changes that could subsequently be accomplished as constitutional amendments. One particular transition stands out. Under the 1788 Constitution, no modification that undermined the autonomy of the states with respect to slavery could be accommodated as a constitutional amendment. Yet once Article V was reconstructed, no constitutional amendment could permit states to create within their borders sub-classes of people like slaves. This Article explores these changes and considers some recent proposed amendments in light of the Reconstruction limits.
The primary purposes of this Article are to restore the early understanding of Article V and to reject the view expressed by modern commentators that the Constitution should be kept largely immune from amendment. A constitutional amendment is a significant event that is not easily achieved, but it is less momentous than a fundamental change to the system of government that results from a revolution or civil war. Amending the Constitution is more serious and difficult than ordinary legislation, but it is much less so than a transformative act by We the People. Article V allows for - indeed invites - citizens to examine in an ongoing fashion the details of their constitutional arrangements and to correct those things that do not serve well the basic design. Rather than keep Article V locked away, beyond the reach of citizens, it is more faithful to the Constitution's design and to the project of self-government to make available the amendment procedure for its deliberately limited uses.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 109
Keywords: Constitutional amendments, Article V, Bill of Rights, Reconstruction, Fourteenth Amendment
JEL Classification: K10, K19Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: September 26, 2005
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo8 in 0.234 seconds