Semiotics, Analogical Legal Reasoning, And The Cf. Citation: Getting Our Signals Uncrossed

Abstract:     
The Bluebook's introductory citation signals are essential to effective legal discourse. The choice of signal can influence not only the interpretation of cited cases, but also the path of law. In this Article, Professor Ira Robins examines one commonly used signal: the cf. After exploring its semiotic function, he details the multitude of ways in which this signal has been used and misused. He argues that lawyers' and judges' careless use of the cf. leads to confusing and often incoherent developments in the law, and concludes by proposing a precise working definition for this irksome, but potentially powerful, citation signal.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 38

Keywords: Semiotics, Signal, Legal Reasoning, Bluebook, Common Law, Introductory Signals, Legal Citation

JEL Classification: K10, K19, K40, K41

Accepted Paper Series