Corporate Governance Consequences of Accounting Scandals: Evidence from Top Management, CFO and Auditor Turnover

Abstract:     
This paper examines the consequences of accounting scandals to top management, top financial officers, and outside auditors. We examine a sample of 518 U.S. public companies that announced earnings-decreasing restatements during the 1997-2002 period and an industry-size matched sample of control firms. Using logistic regressions that control for other determinants of management turnover, we find strong evidence of greater turnover of CEOs, top management and CFOs of restating firms compared to the control sample. The magnitudes of these effects are even larger for restatements that are more serious, have worse effects on stock prices, or result in negative restated earnings. We find no consistent evidence that auditor turnover is higher in restating firms, except for restatements initiated by the company. Our paper provides evidence of effective functioning of internal governance mechanisms following accounting scandals.

Keywords: Management turnover, CFO turnover, Auditor turnover, Accounting scandals, Earnings manipulation, Earnings restatements, Financial restatements

JEL Classifications: G34, M43, K22

Working Paper Series