Using Stock and Stock Options to Minimize Patent Royalty Payment Risks After Medimmune v. Genentech
Sean M. O'Connor
University of Washington School of Law
New York University Journal of Law and Business, Vol. 3, p. 381, 2007
The Supreme Court's recent decision in MedImmune v. Genentech left patent owners who license out their patents in exchange for royalty streams in a bad spot. It is an especially dire spot for patent owners such as universities who incur substantial opportunity costs when they grant an exclusive license to a licensee who pays relatively little up front, in exchange for paying a potentially sizable royalty stream if or when products based on the patents are successfully commercialized and sold in the marketplace. Because the MedImmune decision allows such licensees to bring declaratory judgment actions to invalidate the patent or establish the licensee's products as non-infringing with no particular trigger and without repudiating the licensee (and thus avoiding the possibility of a patent owner suit for infringement), it is expected that licensees will take a license just to buy time to develop a product with relative freedom to operate and then attempt to invalidate the patent once a product looks like it will become profitable and royalties would have to be paid. While some have suggested that the solution to this is simply for patent owners to demand full payment of the net present value of the royalty stream up front, this will simply not be possible for many start up and mid sized companies who license technologies from universities and other routine licensors. The author instead proposes a method for licensors to take some combination of stock and stock options in the licensee - that essentially the licensee can "afford" to pay in the near term even while short on cash and revenues - while still allowing the licensor to participate in the potential upside of a successful commercialization effort of the licensor's patents by the licensee, but in a manner that is fully accrued to the licensor upon the execution of the license.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 63
Keywords: licensing, MedImmune, Genentech, running royalties, tech transfer, patents, universities, start-ups, spin-offs
JEL Classification: D23, D45, K22, M13, O31, O32, O33, O34, O38Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: April 1, 2007 ; Last revised: July 30, 2011
© 2013 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo7 in 0.578 seconds