The Establishment Clause and Religious Expression in Governmental Settings: Four Variables in Search of a Standard
Daniel O. Conkle
Indiana University Maurer School of Law
110 West Virginia Law Review 315 (2007)
Indiana Legal Studies Research Paper No. 81
In his controversial but controlling opinion in Van Orden v. Perry, Justice Breyer rejected an Establishment Clause challenge to a Ten Commandments monument on the grounds of the Texas State Capital. Breyer argued that existing Establishment Clause formulations, including the Lemon and endorsement tests, were inadequate to resolve the case, so he relied instead on legal judgment, an approach informed by doctrinal and policy considerations but not controlled by any formal test.
In this Essay, I suggest that Justice Breyer may have been right in Van Orden-if not in his result, then at least in approaching the question as he did. More generally, I suggest that the search for a clear-cut doctrinal test or rule for religious expression in governmental settings, complete with yes-or-no check-off points, may be a mistaken or futile venture. There simply are too many constitutional values at work, and too many relevant variables.
In lieu of a categorical test or rule, I explore the possibility of a multivariable standard for resolving Establishment Clause questions in this context. Under this approach, the Supreme Court would consider four constitutional variables, which I link to a range of relevant and intersecting constitutional values. The variables address such factors as governmental coercion or aggressiveness, the nature and specificity of the religious expression, tradition, and the extent to which the expression is governmentally-as opposed to privately-crafted or sponsored. I explain and elaborate by applying the multivariable standard to easy cases, not-so-easy cases, and hard cases, including not only Van Orden but also the unresolved controversy over the under God language in the Pledge of Allegiance.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 29
Keywords: Constitutional Law, Constitutional Interpretation, First Amendment, Establishment Clause, Religious Expression and Symbolism, Religious Liberty, Religious Free Speech, Ten Commandments, Pledge of Allegiance, Justice Breyer
JEL Classification: K00, K10, K19, K30, K39Accepted Paper Series
Date posted: June 21, 2007 ; Last revised: June 29, 2013
© 2014 Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
This page was processed by apollo3 in 0.468 seconds