The Sealed-Bid Abstraction in Online Auctions
50 Pages Posted: 8 Nov 2007 Last revised: 1 Apr 2010
Date Written: December 6, 2009
Abstract
This paper presents five empirical tests of the popular modeling abstraction that assumes bids from online auctions with proxy bidding can be analyzed “as if” they were bids from a second price sealed-bid auction. The tests rely on observations of the magnitudes and timings of the top two proxy bids, with the different tests stemming from different regularity assumptions about the underlying distribution of valuation signals. We apply the tests to data from three eBay markets - MP3 players, DVDs, and used cars - and we reject the sealed-bid abstraction in all three datasets. A closer examination of these rejections suggests they are driven by less experienced bidders. This consistent rejection casts doubt on several existing theories of online auction behavior and suggests some demand estimates based on the abstraction can be biased. To assess the direction and magnitude of this bias, we propose and estimate a new model in which some bidders conform to the abstraction while other bidders bid in a reactive fashion. Since reactive bidding can be at least partially detected from the data, we are able to estimate the underlying distribution of demand and compare it to what the sealed-bid abstraction implies. We find that our proposed model fits the data better, and our demand estimates reveal a large potential downward bias were we to assume the second-price sealed-bid model instead.
Keywords: eBay, empirical auctions, sealed bidding, online auction
JEL Classification: D44
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
An Integrated Model for Whether, Who, When, and How Much in Internet Auctions
By Young-hoon Park and Eric Bradlow
-
Bayesian Estimation of Bid Sequences in Internet Auctions Using a Generalized Record Breaking Model
By Eric Bradlow and Young-hoon Park
-
By Song Yao and Carl F. Mela
-
Willingness to Pay and Competition in Online Auctions
By Tat Y. Chan, Vrinda Kadiyali, ...
-
An Integrated Model of Discrete Choice and Response Time
By Thomas Otter, Greg M. Allenby, ...
-
The Dependent Poisson Race Model and Modeling Dependence in Conjoint Choice Experiments
By Shiling Ruan, Steven N. Maceachern, ...
-
Choice Models and Customer Relationship Management
By Wagner A. Kamakura, Carl F. Mela, ...
-
Estimating Functional Agent-Based Models: An Application to Bid Shading in Online Markets Format
By Wei Guo, Wolfgang Jank, ...
-
By Bevan Tipene-matua and Mark Henaghan