Elaborating or Aggregating? The Joint Effects of Group Decision-Making Structure and Systematic Errors on the Value of Group Interactions

47 Pages Posted: 3 Mar 2018

See all articles by Steffen Keck

Steffen Keck

Independent

Wenjie Tang

NUS Business School - Department of Decision Sciences

Date Written: January 1, 2018

Abstract

We explore when group interactions will have a positive effect on the accuracy of quantitative judgments. The results from two laboratory experiments revealed that the value of group interactions, compared to a statistical aggregation of individual judgments, depends strongly on how a group is structured, and that this effect is moderated by the level of systematic error among group members. In particular, when there was a low level of systematic error, group interactions generally provided little value and group structure did not have a significant effect on the value of group interactions. However, when the level of systematic error was high, the value of interactions in groups with a designated group leader was strongly positive and significantly higher than in consensus groups where interactions still provided only little value. Moreover, our analysis showed that this effect was mediated by information elaboration—which was generally higher in leader groups but only had a significant effect on the value of group interactions when there was a high level of systematic error among group members, and not otherwise. Consistent with these findings, we also found that when the level of systematic error was high, leader groups made more judgments that were outside of the range of initial individual judgments than consensus groups. Furthermore, members of leader groups in general spent more time discussing their task, and reported a higher motivation to process information systematically.

Keywords: group judgments, systematic errors, wisdom of the crowd, group processes

JEL Classification: M00, M10, M19

Suggested Citation

Keck, Steffen and Tang, Wenjie, Elaborating or Aggregating? The Joint Effects of Group Decision-Making Structure and Systematic Errors on the Value of Group Interactions (January 1, 2018). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3128219 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3128219

Wenjie Tang

NUS Business School - Department of Decision Sciences ( email )

15 Kent Ridge Drive
Mochtar Riady Building, BIZ 1 8-69
119245
Singapore

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
75
Abstract Views
538
Rank
576,227
PlumX Metrics