The Persistent Puzzles of Safeguards: Lessons from the Steel Dispute
67 Pages Posted: 13 May 2004
Date Written: May 2004
Abstract
The recent WTO dispute between the United States and eight complainant nations over protective measures for the steel industry brought widespread attention to a little known area of WTO law - the rules governing "safeguard measures," the temporary protection of troubled industries against import surges. The use of safeguard measures is normatively controversial, although their welfare implications are much less clear than their critics sometimes suggest. This paper makes the point that WTO rules, as interpreted by recent Appellate Body decisions and applied by the dispute panel in the steel case, pose nearly insurmountable hurdles to the legal use of safeguard measures by WTO members. Among other things, the current interpretation of the "nonattribution" requirement for the use of safeguard measures in the WTO Safeguards Agreement obliges members to make a demonstration that is logically impossible as an economic matter. Those who believe that safeguard measures are merely wasteful protectionism may welcome such impediments to their use, but it is not obvious that the trading system will benefit in the long run, and there can be little doubt that one key objective of the Uruguay Round negotiators - to revive the use of disciplined, temporary safeguard actions - is being frustrated.
Keywords: WTO, steel industry, safeguard measures
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Safeguards and Antidumping in Latin American Trade Liberalization
-
Contingent Protection as Better Insurance
By Thomas Prusa and Ronald D. Fischer
-
Antidumping and Safeguard Mechanisms: The Brazilian Experience, 1988-2003
By Honorio Kume and Guida Piani
-
Political-Economy of Safeguards and Antidumping in Argentina
By Julio J. Nogues and Elias Baracat
-
Political Economy of Antidumping and Safeguards in Argentina
By Julio J. Nogues and Elias Baracat
-
Antidumping and Safeguard Measures in the Political Economy of Liberalization: The Mexican Case
-
By Elias Baracat and Julio J. Nogues
-
Application of Safeguards and Anti-Dumping Duties in Colombia
By Mauricio Reina and Sandra Zuluaga