Reflections on Cultural Superiority and the Just War: A Neomodern Imperative

Documento de Trabajo No. 278

33 Pages Posted: 12 Sep 2007

See all articles by Carlos Escudé

Carlos Escudé

Universidad del CEMA - CEIEG; CONICET

Date Written: November 2004

Abstract

If all cultures are morally equivalent, then all individuals are not essentially endowed with the same human rights, because some cultures award some men more rights than are allotted to other men and women. If, on the other hand, all men and women are endowed with the same human rights, then all cultures are not morally equivalent, because cultures that acknowledge that "all men are created equal" are ethically superior to those that do not. These two statements are mutually contradictory and cannot both be true. Moreover, there is a natural conflict between them, leading to inevitable intra and inter-civilizational clashes. Relativism will confront evolutionism and hierarchical theocracy will confront secularized republicanism. This essay takes sides and argues that cultural superiority can be asserted on two different levels: moral and epistemological. A culture that acknowledges a set of universal human rights is superior to one that does not, even if it often deviates from these very norms. A culture capable of delving into nature increasing life expectancy through scientific discovery is superior to one that cannot. Furthermore, waging war to defend a superior culture is a moral imperative.

Suggested Citation

Escudé, Carlos, Reflections on Cultural Superiority and the Just War: A Neomodern Imperative (November 2004). Documento de Trabajo No. 278. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1013394 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1013394

Carlos Escudé (Contact Author)

Universidad del CEMA - CEIEG ( email )

1054 Buenos Aires
Argentina

HOME PAGE: http://www.cema.edu.ar/ceieg/

CONICET ( email )

Rivadavia 1917
Buenos Aires, Federal Capital C1033AAJ
Argentina

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
65
Abstract Views
716
rank
352,670
PlumX Metrics