The Dispossessed and the Distressed: Conflicts in Land-Related Rights in Transitions from Unlawful Territorial Regimes

CONFLICTS BETWEEN FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS, Eva Brems, ed., Intersentia: Antwerpen, 2008

Hebrew University International Law Research Paper No. 13-07

42 Pages Posted: 17 Oct 2007 Last revised: 15 Apr 2015

See all articles by Yael Ronen

Yael Ronen

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Hebrew University, Faculty of Law, Minerva Center for Human Rights; Academic Center for Science and Law, Hod Hasharon

Abstract

The article concerns the mechanisms adopted for balancing conflicting rights related to privately-owned real property in a discrete category of situations, namely transition from unlawful territorial regimes. It is based on practice in various historical and contemporary cases of transition from unlawful regimes. These transitions were characterized by the need to balance two conflicting principles, namely ex injuria ius non oritur and ex factis ius oritur. They place in direct conflict persons who have been dispossessed of their property by the unlawful regime, and those who have been purportedly given rights in the same property by that regime.

A preliminary issue is the significance that should be attached to the unlawfulness of the purported grant of rights. Another question is whether to grant unqualified priority to one right over the other or to attempt a balance between them, and, in the latter case, whether to take account of the intrinsic characteristics of the rights or of extrinsic factors. An analysis of specific mechanisms adopted by various post-transition regimes reveals that despite the great political differences among them, they share many common features. This phenomenon suggests that there are some principled guidelines in the balancing of the fundamental rights, rather than only ad hoc decisions. The absence of complete uniformity nonetheless highlights the challenges and difficulties involved in the process.

Keywords: dispossession, restitution, land, original owners, current occupants, human rights, Baltic States, TRNC, East Timor, territorial regime, ex injuria

Suggested Citation

Ronen, Yael, The Dispossessed and the Distressed: Conflicts in Land-Related Rights in Transitions from Unlawful Territorial Regimes. CONFLICTS BETWEEN FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS, Eva Brems, ed., Intersentia: Antwerpen, 2008, Hebrew University International Law Research Paper No. 13-07, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1021761

Yael Ronen (Contact Author)

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Hebrew University, Faculty of Law, Minerva Center for Human Rights ( email )

Mount Scopus
Jerusalem, 9190501
Israel

HOME PAGE: http://https://en.law.huji.ac.il/people/yael-ronen

Academic Center for Science and Law, Hod Hasharon ( email )

5 Margoa St.
Hod Hasharon, 45101
Israel

HOME PAGE: http://en.mishpat.ac.il/yael_ronen/

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
228
Abstract Views
1,503
rank
146,787
PlumX Metrics