Ethics and Law in FDA Decisionmaking

63 Pages Posted: 17 Dec 2007 Last revised: 2 Jun 2013

Dov Fox

University of San Diego: School of Law

Date Written: July 18, 2012

Abstract

The Food and Drug Administration, the agency responsible for regulating drugs and devices, determines their approval based exclusive on whether these products are safe and effective. This Article argues that the FDA's singular reliance on these cost/benefit criteria is a mistake for "enhancement" products that treat no medical condition or departure from normal functioning. Agency review of products to improve mood, sharpen memory, smooth wrinkles, and increase height requires richer analysis than safety and efficacy alone allow.

I argue the safety/efficacy framework, codified long before federal lawmakers anticipated the biomedical enhancements on the market today, misses a constellation of concerns that cannot be filtered through the narrow lens of safety and efficacy. I draw on a number of case studies to demonstrate that, however careful the FDA's scrutiny of clinical data about side effects and success rates, its safety/efficacy framework crowds out powerful concerns about subtle coercion, group prejudice, social conformity, competitive fairness, and collective self-defeat. I reject sweeping bans on approval, prescription, off-label use, or direct-to-consumer advertising of enhancement products in favor of reforms that equip administrators to ask the right questions and account for the relevant arguments.

Keywords: FDA, food and drug law, off-label activity, direct-to-consumer advertising, biomedical enhancement, human growth hormone

JEL Classification: I18, L65, L66, I31, K32, O38

Suggested Citation

Fox, Dov, Ethics and Law in FDA Decisionmaking (July 18, 2012). 2005 MICH. ST. L. REV. 1135. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1072064

Dov Fox (Contact Author)

University of San Diego: School of Law ( email )

5998 Alcalá Park
San Diego, CA 92110
United States
(619) 260-4600 (Phone)

HOME PAGE: http://www.sandiego.edu/law/news/news_releases/newslist.php?_focus=44957

Paper statistics

Downloads
260
Rank
95,191
Abstract Views
2,789