Does Transaction Misalignment Matter for Firm Survival at All Stages of the Industry Lifecycle?

Management Science, Vol. 53, pp. 1332-1345, 2007

Posted: 9 Jan 2008

See all articles by Lyda S. Bigelow

Lyda S. Bigelow

University of Utah - David Eccles School of Business

Nicholas S. Argyres

Boston University - School of Management

Abstract

Research on industry lifecycles suggests that competitive pressures are more severe during the shakeout stage, which could be associated with the emergence of a dominant design, than at other stages. Transaction cost theory, on the other hand, assumes generally competitive markets and does not address the industry lifecycle. It therefore implies that transaction cost economizing is a superior firm strategy regardless of the stage of the lifecycle. This paper seeks to reconcile these two streams of research by investigating whether aligning transactions with governance modes in accordance with transaction cost prescriptions has a differential effect on firm survival in pre-shakeout vs. shakeout stages of the industry lifecycle. Analyzing data from the early U.S. auto industry (1917-1933), we find that while transaction misalignment did not have a significant impact on firm survival during the pre-shakeout stage, or during the period as a whole, it did have a significantly larger negative impact on survival during the shakeout stage than during the early fragmentation stage. We also find that the negative effects of misalignment on survival were significantly weaker for larger firms during the shakeout stage. This suggests that applications of transaction cost theory which assume uniformly severe selection pressures across the industry lifecycle, and uniform effects of misalignment across firms of different sizes, could be misleading. It also suggests that theories of the industry lifecycle could usefully take transaction costs into account along with production costs in their analyses of competition over the lifecycle.

Keywords: industry lifecycle, transaction costs, vertical integration

JEL Classification: L22

Suggested Citation

Bigelow, Lyda S. and Argyres, Nicholas S., Does Transaction Misalignment Matter for Firm Survival at All Stages of the Industry Lifecycle?. Management Science, Vol. 53, pp. 1332-1345, 2007, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1081860

Lyda S. Bigelow

University of Utah - David Eccles School of Business ( email )

1645 E Campus Center Dr
Salt Lake City, UT 84112-9303
United States
801-585-3471 (Phone)

Nicholas S. Argyres (Contact Author)

Boston University - School of Management ( email )

595 Commonwealth Avenue
Boston, MA 02215
United States
(617) 353-4152 (Phone)
(617) 353-5003 (Fax)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Abstract Views
496
PlumX Metrics