Access to Justice: The Quality of the Procedure
TISCO Working Paper Series on Civil Law and Conflict Resolution Systems No. 002/2008
44 Pages Posted: 14 Feb 2008 Last revised: 20 Jul 2009
Date Written: February 1, 2008
Abstract
The quality of procedures is believed to play an important role in access to justice. It is assumed, that the quality of a procedure is high if people evaluate it as fair. Fair procedures are likely to improve access to justice. For the purpose of the present paper, the quality of procedures is determined in terms of people's perceptions of procedural justice. Pocedural justice refers to various aspects that a procedure should meet in order to be perceived as fair by its users. Research on procedural justice has a long tradition within the field of social psychology. It was therefore decided to focus on the theoretical and empirical framework of social psychology in order to define and evaluate the quality of procedures. Other frameworks, such as legal, philosophical and economic perspectives, are not discussed here. Various indicators of procedural justice as well as potential factors influencing people's evaluations of procedural justice have been identified in past research. Factors that were found to affect procedural justice perceptions include cultural aspects, features of the outcome, as well as characteristics of the dispute. In addition, recent research has indicated that people may also rely on emotional information when evaluating procedural justice. This aspect seems to be of particular importance in the legal context as conflicts are generally characterised by negative emotions which may then influence people's justice judgments. The present paper discusses the most relevant research findings and theories of procedural justice. In addition, the different conceptualisations of justice and their relevance for the purpose of evaluating the quality of procedures are discussed in more detail in order to determine which indicators of procedural justice are most relevant and should therefore be incorporated into a measurement method to assess the quality of procedures.
Keywords: Procedural justice, Interpersonal justice, Informational justice
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
How to Measure the Price and Quality of Access to Justice?
By Maurits Barendrecht, José Mulder, ...
-
Measuring Access to Justice: The Quality of Outcomes
By Jin Ho Verdonschot, Maurits Barendrecht, ...
-
Measuring the Costs and Quality of Paths to Justice: Contours of a Methodology
By Martin Gramatikov, Maurits Barendrecht, ...
-
Methodological Challenges in Measuring Cost and Quality of Access to Justice
-
Access to Justice, Costs, and Legal Aid
By James George
-
Institutionalizing Access-to-Justice: Judicial, Legislative and Grassroots Dimensions
-
Weighting Justice: Constructing an Index of Access to Justice
-
Online Integrative Negotiation Tools for the Dutch Council for Legal Aid
-
From :-( to :-) Using Online Communication to Improve Dispute Resolution