Political Litigation and the Role of the Court

Supreme Court Law Review, Vol. 34, pp. 35-56, 2006

22 Pages Posted: 3 Mar 2008

See all articles by Grant Huscroft

Grant Huscroft

University of Western Ontario - Faculty of Law

Abstract

The way in which the Supreme Court of Canada deals with politically controversial cases suggests that the Court is self-defining of its role in constitutional litigation, and more broadly in the constitutional order. Recent litigation involving same-sex marriage and the public health care system demonstrates the problem.

In the context of same-sex marriage, the Court had no choice but to hear a reference from the government of Canada seeking advice, yet the Court purported to exercise a discretionary power not to answer the most important question before it: whether or not limiting marriage to opposite-sex couples infringed the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. In the context of the public health care system, the Court had a choice, and it chose to hear an appeal on the constitutionality of Quebec legislation designed to protect the public monopoly on heath care. Having elected to hear that case, however, the Court failed to reach a majority decision on the Charter question, and the failure appears to have been deliberate.

Having deprecated the "passive virtues" and rejected a political questions doctrine, the Supreme Court of Canada nevertheless exercises considerable discretion in dealing with politically controversial cases. It is concerned, among other things, with preserving its political capital in the context of a constitutional order that has become increasingly dependent on its decisions.

Keywords: Constitutional law, judicial review, advisory opinions; passive virtues, political questions, same-sex marriage, health care

JEL Classification: K10

Suggested Citation

Huscroft, Grant, Political Litigation and the Role of the Court. Supreme Court Law Review, Vol. 34, pp. 35-56, 2006, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1099767

Grant Huscroft (Contact Author)

University of Western Ontario - Faculty of Law ( email )

London, Ontario N6A 3K7 N6A 3K7
Canada
519-661-2111 ext 88375 (Phone)
519-661-3790 (Fax)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
240
Abstract Views
2,023
rank
144,383
PlumX Metrics