Let the Beachcomber Drown: Why Taxing Endowment is Unjust

47 Pages Posted: 28 Jan 2007

See all articles by Linda Sugin

Linda Sugin

Fordham University School of Law

Date Written: February 29, 2008

Abstract

Many legal scholars who care about fairness in taxation are increasingly drawn to the idea of endowment taxation - a tax based on a person's ability to earn income, rather than on her actual income. For these scholars, endowment taxation is an appealing model for designing an actual tax system because, unlike income and consumption taxes, an endowment tax cannot be avoided by choosing leisure rather than work and is thus consistent with the intuition that tax should be based on one's ability to pay. This article evaluates equity-driven claims that endowment is the ideal tax base; to the contrary, it argues that the protection of liberty and equality, as understood in liberal egalitarian political theories, prohibits a tax on endowment. The article explains why the economist's attraction to endowment taxation is not compelling to those concerned about fairness. It suggests reframing the debate about tax equity away from so-called beachcombers - people who simply opt out of the social project - to take account of productivity that is undervalued or occurs outside the market. It explains why different deontological theories lead to different conclusions about fair taxes and compares the libertarian approach to endowment taxation with the liberal egalitarian approach. Last, it focuses on the apparent affinity of the equal opportunity norm for endowment taxation, comparing the work of John Rawls and Ronald Dworkin, and concludes that neither philosopher would embrace endowment tax as an ideal.

Keywords: endowment tax, liberal egalitarian, tax justice

Suggested Citation

Sugin, Linda, Let the Beachcomber Drown: Why Taxing Endowment is Unjust (February 29, 2008). Fordham Legal Studies Research Paper No. 959710. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1102370 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1102370

Linda Sugin (Contact Author)

Fordham University School of Law ( email )

140 West 62nd Street
New York, NY 10023
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
256
Abstract Views
1,090
rank
117,796
PlumX Metrics