Justice Hill and the Autopoiesis of Income Tax Law

33 Pages Posted: 19 Mar 2008 Last revised: 13 Oct 2011

See all articles by John Prebble QC

John Prebble QC

Victoria University of Wellington - Faculty of Law; Institut für Österreichisches und Internationales Steuerrecht, Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien; University of Notre Dame Australia - School of Law

Date Written: 2011

Abstract

The theory that law may best be understood as an autopoietic system has gained considerable ground since Luhmann advanced it in 1981.

Nevertheless, there have been few endeavours to apply the theory in any practical way or to employ it to analyze particular areas of law. In a recent paper, Geraldine Hikaka and the present author proposed the thesis that Luhmann's theories usefully illuminate the field of income tax law. The present paper illustrates this thesis by analyzing a leading case from each of the Privy Council and the High Court of Australia, namely Europa Oil (NZ) Ltd v Commissioner of Inland Revenue and Federal Commissioner of Taxation v South Australian Battery Makers Pty Ltd. The paper will argue that the autopoietic nature of income tax law presents challenges to the judicial process that, as these cases illustrate, lead to income tax law becoming detached from the business profits that are an important part of its subject matter.

The paper will then turn to Macquarie Finance Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation, one of the last tax judgments of the late Justice Graham Hill. It will be argued that in Macquarie Finance Ltd Justice Hill demonstrated a rare, almost unique, ability among judges: to reconcile the formalistic, autopoietic nature of tax law with the business substance that was the subject matter of the case. The paper turns first, however, to the question of what is meant by the autopoietic theory of law.

JEL Classification: H2, A1

Suggested Citation

Prebble QC, John, Justice Hill and the Autopoiesis of Income Tax Law (2011). Victoria University of Wellington Legal Research Paper No. 32/2011. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1107662 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1107662

John Prebble QC (Contact Author)

Victoria University of Wellington - Faculty of Law ( email )

PO Box 600
Wellington, 6140
New Zealand
+64 4 463 6311 (Phone)
Papers Indexed at HOME PAGE (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.victoria.ac.nz/law/staff/prebble-scholarly.aspx

Institut für Österreichisches und Internationales Steuerrecht, Wirtschaftsuniversität Wien ( email )

Welthandelsplatz 1
Vienna, Wien 1020
Austria

University of Notre Dame Australia - School of Law

Sydney Campus, New South Wales
Australia

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
231
Abstract Views
1,591
rank
142,450
PlumX Metrics