Footnotes (220)



Errors, Omissions, and the Tennessee Plan

Brian T. Fitzpatrick

Vanderbilt Law School

August 14, 2008

University of Memphis Law Review, Vol. 39, No. 1, 2008
Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper No. 08-49

In the Spring 2008 issue of the Tennessee Law Review, I wrote an essay questioning whether Tennessee's merit system for selecting appellate judges - the Tennessee Plan - satisfies the requirements of the Tennessee Constitution. The Tennessee Constitution requires all judges to be elected by the qualified voters of the state, yet, under the Plan, all appellate judges are initially selected by gubernatorial appointment and then retained in uncontested referenda. I argued that both the appointment and retention features of the Plan are unconstitutional, and I recommended that the legislature refuse to reauthorize the Plan when it expires in June of 2009.

Two very distinguished authors, Penny White, a former Tennessee Supreme Court Justice, and Malia Reddick, a researcher at the American Judicature Society, have published a colorful response to my essay. I have the greatest respect for both Justice White and Ms. Reddick, and I very much appreciate the time they took to read my essay and to comment on it. Unfortunately, however, I found much of their response more colorful than careful. In this reply, I explain why Justice White's constitutional arguments did not cast doubt on any of the conclusions in my original essay. I also explain why Ms. Reddick's policy arguments may have overstated the evidence in favor of so-called merit plans for judicial selection.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 40

Keywords: Tennessee Plan, merit selection, judicial selection, constitutional law

JEL Classification: K10

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: August 15, 2008 ; Last revised: January 13, 2009

Suggested Citation

Fitzpatrick, Brian T., Errors, Omissions, and the Tennessee Plan (August 14, 2008). University of Memphis Law Review, Vol. 39, No. 1, 2008; Vanderbilt Public Law Research Paper No. 08-49. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1152413

Contact Information

Brian T. Fitzpatrick (Contact Author)
Vanderbilt Law School ( email )
131 21st Avenue South
Nashville, TN 37203-1181
United States
615-322-4032 (Phone)

Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 1,266
Downloads: 122
Download Rank: 183,666
Footnotes:  220