Accounting and the Truth of Earnings Reports: Philosophical Considerations

39 Pages Posted: 6 Jul 2008 Last revised: 13 Nov 2008

Norman B. Macintosh

Queen's University

Date Written: July 3, 2008

Abstract

This essay investigates the philosophical nature of accounting reports of earnings. Standard setters' authoritative pronouncements [conceptual frameworks, GAAP, EITFs, etc.] hold to the realist philosophical view that true earnings reports are ex post representations of some ex ante out-there, preexisting, extralinguistic real economic increase in the enterprise's wealth. Contra this view, in practice financial accounting executives, in league with investment analysts, routinely engage in the earnings management and manipulation in order to satisfy the capital market's insatiable demands for earnings levels which will support and enhance the enterprise's stock market price.

The essay considers this state of affairs from Harold Frankfurt's [2005, 2006] truth, lies, and bullshit treatise. It sees earnings reports as short of lies, and so the accountants can only be faulted for their indifference to the truth and for giving the impression that they are trying to present the truth. A poststructuralist philosophical perspective, however, problematizes this conclusion on the basis that accounting language is not a transparent medium but rather is the material used to manufacture accounting truths. It sees accounting truths as contingent upon linguistic doctrinal accounting discourses currently ceded place of privilege by standard setters and upon the subjective considerations of accountants when they produce reports of earnings. The essay concludes that both Frankfurt's perspective and that of poststructuralist philosophers can provide valuable insights into this process.

JEL Classification: M10, M43, M44, G31

Suggested Citation

Macintosh, Norman B., Accounting and the Truth of Earnings Reports: Philosophical Considerations (July 3, 2008). Queen's School of Business Research Paper No. 05-08. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1155184 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1155184

Norman B. Macintosh (Contact Author)

Queen's University ( email )

Kingston, Ontario
613-545-2334 (Phone)
613-545-6847 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
298
Rank
81,764
Abstract Views
1,112